In Defense of Nick Cage: Part One

I know an actor whose career started off really well. Three of his first films were Brubaker, Fast Times at Ridgemont High and The Outsiders, though he was a minor character or uncredited in all three. Of course, his booking these roles, especially the last one, could be attributed to hookups from his famous uncle, Francis Ford Coppola. He then went on to star in some of the biggest Hollywood movies of the 1980s and 1990s.
Now he’s having financial trouble. No one can understand why, especially since he spent so much of the past ten years making bad movies that are clearly cash-grabs. He’s probably going to have to sell one of his many houses or sportscars.
His name is Nicolas Cage, born Nicolas Coppola.
Over the past couple weeks I have gotten into some arguments about Nicolas Cage. Friends of mine, my friend Dave in particular, claim that Nicholas Cage is not a good movie actor. Here is his basic argument:
1. Nick Cage has made a lot of terrible movies
2. In his good movies, he’s carried by great directors or actors
So, his basic premise is that Nicholas Cage is only as good as the director or actors around him. This explains why he is so good in films like Adaptation, Raising Arizona, Wild at Heart, etc. And why he is not so good in films like Knowing, Next, and so many more.
My contention is that Nicholas Cage is a good actor in the same way that David Letterman is a good comedian - he knows how and when to turn it on. Perhaps this miserly desire to only summon talent at will is itself objectionable, but that’s a different debate.
So, in this first part of this Defense of Nick Cage, I will go through a bunch of Nicholas Cage’s movies and classify them, as objectively as possible, as good or bad.
Of the Nicholas Cage films I’ve seen, these are the best, in chronological order:
· Raising Arizona (1987)
· Wild at Heart (1987)
· Leaving Las Vegas (1987)
· The Rock (1996)
· Con Air (1997)
· Face/Off (1997)
· Bringing Out the Dead (1997)
· Gone In Sixty Seconds (2000)
· Adaptation (2002)
· Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans (2009)
Of the Nicholas Cage films I’ve seen, these are the worst, in chronological order:
· 8mm (1999)
· The Wicker Man (2006)
· Ghost Rider (2007)
I know that the analytical reader will say “Hey - you’ve only seen the best and the worst of his films, which is all that anyone would see. That doesn’t give you a fair indication of all of his work – specifically, the middling crap that differentiates between ok and great careers.” Fair enough. Let’s just postulate that my argument here in Part One will be based on these best and worst films. The great unwashed middle will be examined in a later part of this essay.
Let’s start with his good (and great) films. These ten were directed by, respectively:
· The Coen Brothers (Raising Arizona)
· David Lynch (Wild at Heart)
· Mike Figgis (Leaving Las Vegas)
· Michael Bay (The Rock)
· Simon West (Con Air)
· John Woo (Face/Off)
· Martin Scorcese (Bringing Out the Dead)
· Dominic Sena (Gone in Sixty Seconds)
· Spike Jonze (Adaptation)
· Werner Herzog (Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call, New Orleans)
At this point, my argument is not looking good. Of these ten, five were directed by arguably (and in different ways) five of the best directors currently working (Coens, Lynch, Scorcese, Jonze, Herzog). Two (Woo, Bay) are great action film directors. The other three (Figgis, West, Sena) are nothing special.
Then let’s look at his costars in these films, again, respectively:
· Holly Hunter, Frances McDormand (Raising Arizona)
· Laura Dern, Willem Dafoe, Diane Ladd, Harry Dean Stanton (Wild at Heart)
· Elisabeth Shue (Leaving Las Vegas)
· Sean Connery, Ed Harris, Michael Biehn, William Forseyth (The Rock)
· John Cusack, John Malkovich, Ving Rhames, Mykelti Williamson, Nick Chinlund, Steve Buscemi, Monica Potter (Con Air)
· John Travolta (Face/Off)
· John Goodman, Ving Rhames,Tom Sizemore, Patricia Arquette (Bringing Out the Dead)
· Angelina Jolie, Giovanni Ribisi, Robert Duvall (Gone in Sixty Seconds)
· Meryl Streep, Chris Cooper, Brian Cox, Tilda Swinton, Maggie Gyllenhall (Adaptation)
· Eva Mendes, Val Kilmer, Xzibit (Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call, New Orleans)
Again, this list with a few exceptions is incredibly strong. In a list of the top 50 living film actors, there’s probably at least ten in this group.
Now, let’s look at his god-awful films. Who directed them?
· 8mm (1999) - Joel Schumacher
· The Wicker Man (2006) - Neil LaBute
· Ghost Rider (2007) - Mark Steven Johnson
All three of these directors have turned out some pretty crappy movies, granted. But who worked with Cage in these films?
· Joaquin Phoenix, James Gandolfini, Catherine Keener
· Ellen Burstyn, Frances Conroy, Molly Parker
· Eva Mendes, Wes Bentley, Sam Elliot, Donal Logue, Peter Fonda
These actors are all extremely talented, though perhaps a few had seen better days.
The conclusion that must be drawn: Nicholas Cage’s best movies were made with great directors, his worst with bad directors, but the casts around him were basically neutral. But I would argue that the failures of these films are not Cage’s fault.
On a film set, the success or failure of a film rests, ultimately, in the hands of the director. As you can see from the lists of movies above, as time went on, Cage, like many actors, got lazy and his consistency started to fade. In that stage of an actor’s career, it is most vital that they have a strong director on the set.
Otherwise, what happens is a seedy piece of garbage (8mm), an overwrought, overacted, ridiculous remake (The Wicker Man), or a botched blockbuster where the actors don’t appear to even be talking to one another on screen (Ghost Rider). Ultimately, these three cinematic abortions were clearly the progeny of their directors - an old cheeseball, a stage director who traffics in gluts of shock, and an inexperienced director way out of his league.
So Dave, and all you other Cage-haters out there, you were right about one thing. Nick Cage does step up his performances for great directors. But who wouldn’t? Cage is a mid-life Hollywood actor. He works for money. But, when he does get a project worthy of his talents, he knocks it out of the park.
In the next part of this essay, I will look at the good films that I claim Cage has made, and answer the questions: Were these films really good? And if so, how integral was he to their success? And with the failures, how much of that was his fault?